Volume 14 Issue 1 (2025)
1

A Systematic Review on Indigenous Pedagogies in Education

pp. 7-20  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.1

Cristine Mae E. Arevalo , Gerico Pangilinan , Jonnell G. Borabo , Shane D. Escalante , Jocelyn A. Gueta , Joyce D. Deladia , Gerry S. Digo

Abstract

Background/purpose. This study aims to identify, describe, and explain how Indigenous pedagogies are integrated in education to promote students’ learning.

Materials/methods. This study employed a systematic review and meta-synthesis to explore the role of Indigenous pedagogies in education in promoting students' learning outcomes. In total, 12 articles met the criteria for a systematic review using the Llama software tool.  The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 guidelines guided the development and presentation of this systematic review.

Results. The study revealed seven major themes: decolonization, Indigeniation, and cultural safety; relational and community-based learning; holistic and transformative education; critical and culturally sustainable pedagogy; Afrocentric-indigenous pedagogy for inclusive education; innovative and contextual learning; and service-learning and reflective practice. Overall, integrating Indigenous pedagogies leads to improved academic outcomes, increased cultural awareness, and a greater appreciation for diverse perspectives in education.

Conclusion. Integrating Indigenous pedagogies in education has a profound impact on students, schools, and communities. Incorporating Indigenous cultures' traditional knowledge, values, and teaching methods helps promote cultural diversity, respect, and understanding among students. These approaches also enhance the educational experiences of Indigenous students by validating their identity, language, and heritage within the curriculum. Furthermore, they foster learners' critical consciousness and a more inclusive learning environment that empowers students to connect with their roots and develop a strong sense of belonging.

Keywords: Indigenous education, Indigenous pedagogy, Systematic review

2

Students’ Attitudes and Perceptions of Classroom Learning Environment: An Analysis of their Interrelationship and Influence on Academic Achievement in Biology

pp. 21-42  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.2

Emmanuel Bizimana , Gabriel Janvier Tugirinshuti , Aimable Sibomana

Abstract

Background/purpose. In the context of education, the perceived classroom learning environment (CLE) and attitudes have a significant impact. There is a connection between the two that cannot be broken. Given this relationship, both are relevant components in Biology teaching and learning. Thus, this study examined the relationships among students’ perceptions of CLE, attitudes towards Biology, and their influence on students’ academic achievement in Biology.

Materials/methods. A correlation research design was adopted for the study. The study's target population comprised all senior two secondary school students studying biology in the Nyamagabe district of Rwanda. A purposive sampling technique was used to select 7 boarding secondary schools, with a total of 449 students. The What Is Happening in this Class (WIHIC) and Biology Attitude Questionnaire (BAQ) were the data collection instruments. Descriptive statistics, t-tests, correlational analyses, and multiple linear regression were used to analyze the data.

Results. The study revealed that students' perceptions of CLE, attitudes towards Biology, and their academic achievement in the subject were significantly and positively correlated. Both CLE and attitudes positively predicted students' academic achievement in Biology. Gender significantly affects students' perceptions of the CLE, with females having more favorable attitudes than males.

Conclusion. The study results indicated a positive and significant association between learning environment, attitudes, and academic achievement in Biology. Thus, the more students perceive the CLE favorably, the more likely they are to develop positive attitudes toward biology, which in turn enhances their academic achievement, and vice versa.

Keywords: Academic achievement, attitude, biology, classroom learning environment, gender

3

Shaping Faculty Teaching Beliefs

pp. 43-57  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.3

Jeyran Aghayeva

Abstract

Background/purpose. Faculty beliefs influence their teaching behaviors, making understanding how these beliefs are formed an important research topic. Yet little is known about the phenomenon in culturally and economically diverse settings. This paper explores the role of various factors in shaping faculty teaching beliefs in post-Soviet Azerbaijan.

Materials/methods. The qualitative data in this study were collected through two-cycle semi-structured interviews with faculty members working in Azerbaijani higher education institutions. The smallest meaningful units were identified and used to construct categories.

Results. The results show that the faculty's teaching beliefs are embedded in larger environments within which they live and interact with others. The data suggest that environmental, individual, and institutional-level factors shaped participants’ beliefs about teaching.

Conclusion. Faculty teaching beliefs are formed and can be further shaped as they engage in learning within and outside academe. The findings suggest that supportive institutional environments can facilitate faculty learning to promote faculty engagement in a specific teaching method.

Keywords: Faculty teaching, teaching beliefs, higher education, teaching, Azerbaijan

4

Disability-Inclusive Early Childhood Care and Education in Tanzania: Exploring Challenges of Quality Nurturing

pp. 58-73  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.4

Juhudi Karugendo Cosmas

Abstract

Background/purpose. Globally, early childhood care and education (ECCE) has become a national priority. In addition to fostering physical, emotional, social, and cognitive development, nurturing care in disability-inclusive ECCE helps shield young children from the harshest consequences of hardship. The purpose of this study was to examine the main difficulties in providing nurturing care in disability-inclusive ECCE.

Materials/methods. A collective case study design served as the foundation for this qualitative study. A purposeful sample of 25 participants was selected. Focus groups and semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. Data was analysed in several stages using content analysis.

Results. The findings showed that nurturing care was inadequately addressed, even when disability-inclusive ECCE was offered. In ECCE programmes, there were no effective inclusive practices to help children with disabilities reach their full potential.

Conclusion. It was concluded that ECCE for children with disabilities was provided in a challenging environment that required immediate interventions. To make disability-inclusive ECCE a feasible procedure, school administration and other stakeholders should overcome the obstacles to nurturing care.

Keywords: Disability, early childhood care, education, nurturing care

5

The Relationship Between School Organizational Structure and Tokenism Perception: A Study Based on Teachers' Views

pp. 74-92  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.5

Oğuz Gürbüz , Tuncay Yavuz Özdemir

Abstract

Background/purpose. The main purpose of this research is to examine "the relationship between the structure of schools and teachers' perceptions of tokenism" with the relational research model, one of the quantitative research methods.

Materials/methods. The sample group is based on data from 507 teachers, obtained through convenience sampling. Research findings revealed that obstructive bureaucracy in schools had positive and significant effects on all three dimensions of tokenism.

Results. This result showed that bureaucratic restrictions in schools increased teachers' perceptions of tokenism. It has been concluded that obstructive bureaucracy, characterized by strict rules and centralist structures, strengthens teachers' perceptions of tokenism. It was determined that the school structure facilitative bureaucracy dimension showed a negative relationship with all sub-dimensions of tokenism, and had a low-level significant effect, especially in the "raised boundaries" dimension. This finding demonstrated that a facilitative school structure can reduce teachers' perceptions of tokenism. Finally, the research revealed that gender differences also influence teachers' perceptions of both tokenism and school structure.

Conclusion. In this context, the importance of building inclusive, equitable, and supportive school structures has been highlighted to prevent gender-based symbolic pressures and role limitations.

Keywords: Discrimination, tokenism in teachers, tokenism, school structure, obstructive bureaucracy, facilitating bureaucracy

6

Chinese Language Education in Kenya: A Case Study of Confucius Institute at the University of Nairobi

pp. 93-110  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.6

Peter Gikonyo , Mercy Mweni Kathina , Fredrick Okoth Otieno , Maureen Achieng Ooko

Abstract

Background/purpose. Cultural strategy is an important part of China's global strategic framework. As China becomes more involved on the global stage, its national strategic interests expand to all corners of the world. One way China has accomplished this is by promoting and propagating the Chinese language in many countries' educational systems. Kenya's education system integrated Chinese language teaching and learning in 2019. It is critical to assess the importance and strategic impact of cultural soft power on Kenya's social, political, and economic development.

Materials/methods. This paper employs questionnaires, interviews, observations, participatory methods, and a literature review approach to elucidate discussions, recommendations, and conclusions.

Results – Few studies have examined the impact of the Chinese language in Kenya, particularly on Kenyans' socio-economic well-being. However, no major study has examined the status, progress, and future aspirations in teaching and learning Chinese language and culture in Kenya.

Conclusion. To achieve the intended results and make the advancement of Chinese language teaching and learning more relevant to people's needs, a clear language policy is required to guide the reorganization, evaluation, and adjustment of its operationalization.

Keywords: Chinese language, Confucius Institute at the university of Nairobi, Kenya, teaching and learning

7

Blind Teachers' Perspectives on the Difficulties They Face in the Workplaces in Tanzania

pp. 111-123  |  Available Online: June 2025  |  DOI: 10.22521/unibulletin.2025.141.7

Sweetbertha Neema Mugassa , Juhudi Karugendo Cosmas

Abstract

Background/purpose. The literature supports the idea that blind people, including teachers, work in a variety of jobs and do their jobs well. This study intended to explore how blind teachers perceive the difficulties they encounter in inclusive teaching in the school environment.

Materials/methods. In this qualitative study and phenomenological design, face-to-face interviews generated data. Participants were blind teachers. The sample consisted of 15 participants. A thematic analysis was conducted.

Results. The findings were deficiencies in the actual physical workspace, transportation, discrimination, insufficient appropriate accommodations, insufficient assistive equipment and teaching materials, and a dearth of opportunities for professional advancement.

Conclusion. Although Tanzania seeks to engage teachers with disabilities as role models in schools and education, several challenges remain standing in the way of achieving this goal. As a result, schools, local governments, and other national education stakeholders need to take more action.

Keywords: Blind teachers, inclusive education, inclusive teaching, right to work, workplace

Announcement

UNIBULLETIN News!

► New issue coming soon! (Volume 14 Issue 2, 2025)

Call for Papers

UNIBULLETIN is calling for submissions. Authors are invited to submit papers from the all areas of social sciences (miscellaneous) and related disciplines in the international context. All submissions should be presented only in English.